Skip to main content
Hot off the Presses.
Woman looking at Instagram competitor analysis on a laptop.

How to Perform a Competitive Analysis On Instagram 

Written by Gina Buggy on .

“Keep your friends close but your enemies closer.” Who would have thought that would be true for social media too?

If you’re wondering how you can outrank your competition on Instagram, the answer might surprise you. It’s not about posting more or trying harder. It’s about studying and understanding your competition.

Instagram is more crowded than ever. There are more than 200 million businesses active on the platform globally. That’s A LOT of competition. But don’t worry. That doesn’t mean there’s not room for you too.

Millions of businesses mean millions of existing strategies at your fingertips. By running a competitor analysis on Instagram, you gain invaluable insights on scaling your business and winning big in the digital space.

Let’s get into it.

What is a Social Media Competitive Analysis?

A competitive analysis is the process of identifying, researching and evaluating your competitors to understand what works for them, what doesn’t and how you can do it better.

On Instagram, this means examining how competing brands appear in the feed, identifying the type of content that drives the most engagement and identifying gaps that can be filled.

Basically, you want to do a deep dive on your biggest ops and find out how you can beat them at their own game. Done right, a competitive analysis isn’t about copying. It’s about finding patterns, spotting opportunities and building a solid content strategy that makes your content stand out.

What are the Benefits of Analyzing Competitors on Instagram?

Every good marketing strategy starts with analyzing your competitors. Forget wasting time on trying to reinvent the wheel. If your engagement sucks, the fastest way to level up your Instagram strategy is by studying your competitors’ content and figuring out what works and what doesn’t.

A solid Instagram competition analysis will help you:

  • Benchmark performance: Understand where you stand in your niche compared to established brands.
  • Stay ahead of trends: Spot the content formats, hooks and hashtags that are gaining traction. There are usually predictions for annual trends that you can capitalize on early by running a competitive analysis.
  • Identify opportunities: Identify where your competitors are inconsistent or absent, so you can capitalize on that space with your own authentic content.
  • Make smarter investments: Decide where to spend your time and budget based on proven results in your market.
  • Reduce risk: Learn from competitor missteps so you don’t waste time on strategies that don’t work.

How to Analyze Competitors’ Social Media

There are a lot of different ways you can do a competitive analysis. And honestly, there’s no one right way to do it. Whether you decide to dig in yourself, invest in tools or hand it off to a pro will largely depend on how much time and resources you have at your disposal.

Manual Research

I’ll be honest with you…this route isn’t glamorous. But if you’re working on a lean budget, it’ll get the job done. Start by identifying your top 5-10 competitors. Scroll through their feeds and stories and take notes on:

  • Their most popular posts (look at likes, comments and saves)
  • The hooks they use in Reels and captions
  • Sounds, trends and hashtags they’re using
  • How they engage in comments

The downside? Manual research is time-consuming and has a limited scope. You’ll get a general feel for their strategy but miss out on deeper data points like follower growth rates, paid ad spend and audience demographics. And let’s be honest. If you’re an entrepreneur, you’re probably already pressed for time.

Use Competitor Analysis Tools

Competitor analysis tools give you a data-driven edge when it comes to social media strategies. Yes, most of them come with a price tag. But they’ll save you hours of scrolling and reveal metrics you can’t pull manually. Some solid options include:

If you’re serious about scaling your business, investing in a social analysis platform is worth it.

Hire a Social Media Manager

If your budget allows, outsourcing competitor analysis to a pro is a game-changer. A social media manager won’t just pull numbers; they’ll interpret them, identify trends and turn insights into an actionable strategy.

Plus, your social media manager will likely have access to all of those pricey tools you would have to buy (and learn).

Think of it this way: tools give you data, but social media managers give you context and execution. If you want consistent, growth-focused results, hiring a pro should realistically pay for itself.

What to Measure In a Competitive Analysis on Social Media

The real value of competitive analysis lies in examining measurable data. These numbers highlight patterns you can benchmark against and use to shape your own Instagram strategy:

  • Audience demographics: Who follows them? Look at age, location and interests to see how your target audience overlaps, or where you can capture untapped segments.
  • Follower growth rate: Rapid growth signals momentum. Slow or stagnant numbers may indicate that their content is no longer connecting with their social media community.
  • User engagement: Likes, comments, shares and saves are all forms of engagement that will show whether people are just watching or actually interacting with their content.
  • Top-performing posts: Which pieces of content consistently outperform the rest? Study their hooks, visuals and timing.
  • Content types: Reels, carousels, single-image posts, stories — each format tells you what the audience prefers and how the algorithm is rewarding content.
  • Hashtags and keywords:  A competitors’ hashtag strategy is a free peek into how they’re optimizing for discoverability. Are they utilizing branded hashtags, keywords or SEO optimization?
  • Ad spend and campaigns: Some Instagram competitor analysis tools will allow you to see what social media ads they’re running, how often and what they’re testing.
  • Posting frequency and consistency: Do they show up daily, weekly or sporadically? Getting on a solid posting schedule is often as important as quality.

Turning Insights Into Strategy

Collecting competitor data is only half the job. The real payoff comes when you turn those insights into action. Here’s how to put your Instagram competitive analysis to work:

  • Filling gaps in competitor strategies: Look at where your competitors are falling short and make those opportunities your own. If they’re ignoring Reels, skipping trending audio or posting inconsistently, you can show up more consistently and capture the engagement they’re missing.
  • Establish your own KPIs: Use competitor performance as your benchmark. If they’re averaging a 5% engagement rate, that number should become the new standard you aim to meet or exceed. This gives you a clear way to track social media KPIs and evaluate whether your content is effective.
  • Adjust your posting schedule: Posting cadence is a critical insight. If top players in your niche are posting four times a week while you’re only posting once a month, it may be a clear sign that your inconsistencies are holding you back.
  • Update your social media calendar: Competitor insights should shape your calendar so it’s driven by data. Use what you learn about timing, formats and themes to plan posts that are more likely to resonate with your audience.
  • Track ROI: Monitoring where competitors allocate their time and ad dollars helps you assess whether your own spend is worthwhile. This helps you focus resources on effective strategies that deliver strong ROI.
  • Spot keyword opportunities: Competitor hashtags, captions and bios are a goldmine for language and phrases (aka social media keywords) that drive discoverability. Use these insights to refine your own keyword and hashtag strategy so your content has a better chance of being found.
  • Boost engagement: By identifying the types of posts that spark the most engagement in your niche, you can create similar formats with your own unique spin to encourage saves, comments, shares and follows.

Ready to Outperform Your Competition?

We’ve unpacked what Instagram competitor analysis is, why it matters and how to get started. Now the question is — what will you do with that knowledge?

If you are ready to move past trial and error and start building an Instagram competitor analysis to skyrocket your marketing, Do Epic Shit Media is here for your brand. Just shoot us a message and let us know how we can help!